4 minutes read

Should I Repair or Replace My Furnace?

Stephen Jabro

How to Know When You Need a New Heating System

It’s a question just about every homeowner has had to face at least once. When is it time to finally retire your old furnace and get a new heating system?

When Your Furnace Needs Repaired:
It’s often some situation that puts a homeowner in this position. Have you had to deal with more than a few repairs on your existing heating system or are you facing a pretty expensive fix on a unit that may be past its prime?

When it’s Just Not Cutting It:
Perhaps you’re more of a proactive homeowner who doesn’t want to wait until your furnace starts to fail you before you get it replaced. Maybe you’ve noticed that your house isn’t getting consistently as warm this winter as in past years? Or you’ve noticed your energy bills rise and know that old low-efficiency heating system is making those monthly expenses worse.

Deciding if I Should Replace my Furnace? The 3 Questions to Ask:

  1. How old is your furnace?
    If you think you had your current furnace installed back around the turn of the millennium, then yes –  now is a good time for an upgrade. Typically, most furnaces can be expected to last 17-20 years. But how long an individual heater will continue working properly often depends on how well it’s been maintained over the years. Its age isn’t the only determining factor. There are times when it’s best to replace a unit, even one that is perhaps only a decade old.
  1. How expensive are your monthly energy bills?
    Have you seen your home’s heating bills continue to go up and up? That extra money you’re spending each money isn’t coming back. But the extra money you spend toward a newer, high-efficient furnace is an investment that pays off. You won’t just feel more comfortable, you should also see your monthly expenses decrease from it’s improved efficiency.
  1. Chart showing age and repair cost factors determining whether you should repair or replace my furnaceHow much is the impending repair job?
    If you are in the unfortunate position of having a broken furnace, or one that is in need of some repair, how much that repair will cost you is important. Is it a small amount? Or are you faced with something that’s going to cost you several of hundreds of dollars? Things like a cracked heat exchanger or other broken components can lead to high repair costs that may not be worth it. How expensive does a repair on your furnace need to be before it’s not worth it?

Refer to this chart from the U.S. Energy Department on how to make a good decision on whether to go for a repair or for a completely new furnace. Consider the age of your unit and the cost of needed repairs.

Need a Professional Furnace Opinion?

furnace repair and new heating system technician

The furnace experts at Jon Wayne Heating & Air see these issues all the time. We often are called upon to assess a home’s heating system and help give homeowners the options and information they need to know in determining whether a furnace is no longer worth repairing. From gas furnaces to electric furnaces, we have qualified and experienced technicians who’ve been fixing heating problems in homes in Springfield, Mt Vernon and surrounding communities for decades.

So if you’re wondering what to do about your problem furnace, call us at (417) 831-9500 in Springfield or (417) 466-2515 in Mt Vernon.  Or contact us online and we will help you determine if your furnace is in good shape to continue working well for more Missouri winters.

Recent Posts


Trusted Heating & Air Specialists

in Springfield & Mt Vernon

With more than 20 years of experience servicing homes and businesses in Springfield, Mt Vernon and surrounding Missouri communities, Jon Wayne Heating & Air is the company you can trust for professional quality service. With 100s of positive reviews, we are the heating and air company relied upon to provide the most efficient and reliable heating and cooling systems to homes across southwest Missouri.


From the S Kansas Expressway, exit on Bennett St. heading west, then turn right on S. Scenic Ave and we’ll be on your right. Coming from W. Sunshine Street, you’ll take S. Scenic Ave going north and we’re just about a mile up the road on your right at 1324 S. Scenic Ave.

Mt Vernon

We are conveniently located right off Highway 39 on the northeast part of town. From W. Mt Vernon Blvd (Hwy 265), turn to go north on Hwy 39.
You’ll find us just about a mile up the road by turning left onto
Breckenridge Rd.

  • Licensed and Insured
  • Professionally Trained
  • Drug Tested
  • Background Checked

Contact Us Today!

We Are Here For You!

    Contact Us Today

    Heating & Air Conditioning Experts

    Serving Springfield & Mt Vernon
    Springfield Office

    1324 Scenic Ave Ste A, Springfield, MO 65802

    (417) 831-9500
    Mt Vernon Office

    726 Breckenridge Rd, Mt Vernon, MO 65712

    (417) 466-2515